This last week has been all about recipe testing. Trying new recipes, changing up the order of ingredients, finding "the" recipes and methods that yield the texture and taste that I am looking for. It's seriously a lot of fun! I love comparing recipes and seeing for myself what an extra yolk will do to the flavor of a vanilla sablé recipe, or what replacing the icing sugar with granulated sugar does to the texture.
Of course, the "downside" is the number of cookies I end up making to do all these tests. And, if you happen to go to the gym with me, you will end up cornered in the locker room and swayed into following up your sweaty efforts with a cookie taste test that will annihilate all the efforts from that grueling bootcamp class (Sorry gym buddies! I love you!).
In the search of my favorite vanilla sablé recipe, I tested 4 different recipes:
- Dorie Greenspan recipe #1, featuring both granulated and powdered sugar
- Dorie Greenspan recipe #2 from her Beurre et Sel bakery, featuring a slightly different ration of granulated and powdered sugar, but also an extra yolk
- My own recipe, based on Dorie's second recipe, but in mine I eliminated the powdered sugar and replaced it with granulated sugar
- Patrice Demers' (one of Montreal's top pastry chefs) recipe that features only granulated sugar, more yolks, baking powder, and a very different mixing method to make the dough
The gym girls preferred recipe #4, though K commented that it tasted eggy. Very true. Recipe #4 has more yolks. They liked the look of the #4 cookie as well, which is funny because I didn't like its look at all. Their choice: 4 > 3 > 2 > 1. #4 was the clear winner.
I also subjected my family to the same taste test. For them, #4 wasn't the winner. My family could tell apart the cookies made with a mix of granulated and icing sugar, from those made with just granulated sugar. The remark: the cookies made with icing sugar were more tender, and perhaps more like a shortbread. The results again were mixed, and there wasn't a clear winner, though once again, #1 was the loser. #2 and #3 were tied. 2 ~ 3 > 4 > 1
What do I think? Well, I didn't like #4. I found it too eggy. I didn't like it's look, and it was obvious that the egg yolks made it yellower, spread more, and I suspect the baking powder made it brown a little more than the others. I did appreciate the fact that #4 had a more "sablé" (sandy) texture though.
I honestly preferred #3, which was my recipe. I didn't like the extra tenderness from the icing sugar in #1 and #2. I didn't really like the look and taste of #4. I preferred the taste and texture of #3 so that's the recipe I'm sharing with you (the other three recipes are available online at the links I provided above).
Vanilla sablésPublished: February 4th, 2013, Cook time: 15–20 minutes
Makes about a dozen cookies
- 115 grams (1/2 cup) unsalted butter, room temperature
- 1/4 tsp salt
- 1 large egg yolk
- 75 grams granulated sugar
- 1 tsp vanilla extract
- 140 grams (1 cup) all-purpose flour
- Handful coarse cane sugar or sanding sugar
- In the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, cream the butter, salt, and sugar.
- Add the yolk and beat, scraping down the sides as needed, then add the vanilla.
- Add the flour and mix just until combined.
- Turn out the dough on a worksurface and form a log with ~2 inch diameter (you can roll it in coarse raw cane sugar or sanding sugar to give your cookies a crunchy sugary edge), then wrap the log in plastic wrap and refrigerate several hours, or overnight.
- Preheat the oven to 350°F. Slice the log into 1/4 inch slices and arrange on a parchment lined baking sheet.
- Bake for about 15–20 minutes, or until the edges just begin to turn golden. Cool on a wire rack before serving.